Why Creative SEO beats technical SEO hands down

Technical SEO is one of the things they gave SEO such a bad name.

Technical SEO was sometimes now referred to as old school SEO.

It would use a set of words terms and language that in the sense was designed to give SEO some sort of mystique that would make it well outside of the re-met and understanding of your average marketing bod and hence the reason why you should PAY an SEOer.

Terms like canonical domain checks, robots.txt, HTML / W3C validated alt tags metadata and headings analysis all part of this vocabulary.

Even in 2021, if you search Google for a free site audit, the software will scan your webpage and basically count the numbers of certain code/HTML features.

Canonical domain issues and choices really means whether or not to use www .before the domain or not.

Metadata is just really a way of saving a file with a name and description. Robots txt is simply a small text document that is used by search engines to take instructions from ie do not index my login page.

URL is SEO friendly, if not then there are lots of shaking of heads, means is your URL ie the address of your webpage in simple words as opposed in numbers ///4343/ref= etc.

Headers analysis is simply the titles within the content, do I make them H1 or H2. Neither is actually correct. H2 only has reference only if there is an H1.

Instead, you could have actually had H4 and H5, the preceding had a value that gives reference to the following value.

Alt tags are simply an old fashion way of giving an image and alternative (hence alt) description, so that should a browser not load images at least the words would appear giving the user at least an indication of what the image may have been.

An old school technical SEO would practically have a coronary if your meta title is less than 70 characters.

Technical SEO has not really developed over the last 5 years

There has seen a number of additions which include page size and loading time, whether or not your website’s mobile-friendly.
A few new rules have appeared like you should have at least 2000 words on your home page.

Social media has appeared, is a website of a link to Twitter, is there a blog on your website and lastly some reason the Holy Grail is your site is accessible via HTTPS (SSL).

Is any of this relevant 2020-wise?

My major concern with technical SEO is that it never sheds old rules, merely adds new ones.

Vanilla Circus© have researched every one of the commonly held SEO truisms and has found that although the majority have grains of truth they are far too simplistic.

For example, does your website have a link to Twitter, does your website have a link to Facebook? I would agree that all of these are trust signals that Google interprets and measures against the overall score of the website.

The higher the score the hire appears in Google ranking.

However, what is not clear is do you actually have to link to your own Twitter account or could you just link to someone else’s Facebook account.

We created a testbed of over 500 websites we tested myths like building backlinks with exact match anchor text, whether or not links all from a single IP recounted in any way differently. We also looked at HTTPS and compared websites with and without.

Our own algorithm

What we discovered we put into our own algorithm which we run against websites. This gives a score that we think reflects Google scoring. In a sense, this is the secret of Vanilla Circus’s success.

Technical SEO still takes precedence over creative SEO. The major complaint we hear from new clients is that all their old SEO agency does is alter meta tags and alt tags whilst ensuring that each page has an H1 heading.

Technical SEO in the style is more based in 2010 and doesn’t take into consideration all of the changes and improvements that Google has made to its algorithm.

Technical SEO metrics are so easy to manipulate

The majority of technical SEO metrics are so easy to manipulate. For example, meta keywords who hasn’t been guilty of adding so many additional keywords. This problem means that technical SEO signals have been downgraded in Google’s algorithmic scoring.

This does not mean they’re not important, it is just that their importance has been superseded by Google’s advancing technology. (Google scoring the website can be anything from 0 to Infinity.)

One of the reasons why the same website is number one for a keyword for what seems like decades is because the scorer of this website far exceeds the websites that rank second third and fourth.

On the technical SEO metrics we have spoken about invariably only ever score 1. So undertaking correct meta data, alt tags etc. are unlikely to make very much difference to your Google page position.

We still teach technical SEO. To us, it is just best practice. All new technicians are shown the very best way of using these metrics to improve the work they do.

However it is the work they do, the content they create the site architecture, the internal and external linking structure and the use of language, words synonyms antonyms and sentence structures that actually command the highest scores within Google’s algorithm.

This is what we refer to as creative SEO. This is what I do.

Author: Benedict Sykes is the senior consultant at VC.


Last checked and updated on March 11, 2021